... Skip to main content

Printone

Photocopier vs. Multifunction Printer: Which Should Your Office Choose?

Photocopier vs. Multifunction Printer: Which Should Your Office Choose?

Choosing between a photocopier and a multifunction printer can be confusing for an IT or procurement executive. Before deciding, it helps to understand the difference between the two. A photocopier traditionally does one job, which is copying. A multifunction printer, as its name suggests, does several jobs, including printing, photocopying, scanning and sometimes faxing. To make the right choice, you first need to analyse the operations of each department that relies on a printer or copier.

That is the classic way to separate them. In practice, the line has blurred. Many modern photocopiers also print and scan over the network, and many multifunction printers copy very well. So the more useful question is not only what the machine can do, but how much work it will have to do, and what kind of work that is.

Step 1: Map what each department actually needs

Start with people, not products. Ask each department what they print, copy and scan on a normal day, and on their busiest day.

  • Finance and accounts: Invoices, statements and supporting documents. Scanning to archive matters as much as printing, and volumes spike at month-end and year-end.
  • HR: Contracts, ID copies and confidential files. Secure printing and scan-to-email matter more than speed.
  • Sales and marketing: Colour proposals, brochures and presentations. Colour quality and larger paper sizes matter.
  • Administration and reception: Occasional copying, visitor forms and general printing. Simplicity and low running cost matter.
  • Legal, PRO and document services: Many copies of original documents, scanning and stapled sets. Speed and finishing options matter.
  • Engineering and projects: A3 sheets and drawings. Paper size and, for large drawings, a separate plotter may be needed.
  • Operations and logistics: Delivery notes, forms and labels. Reliability matters, because a stopped machine stops the line.

Write down the rough pages per month, the paper sizes and whether colour is needed for each team. This simple list will answer half of your questions.

Step 2: Check the eight factors that decide the choice

  1. Volume. How many pages will your office produce each month? Light-use offices are usually well served by a compact multifunction printer. Heavy-use offices usually need a copier-class machine built for large volumes. Ask your supplier for the machine’s recommended monthly volume, and choose one comfortably above your busy months, not just your average.
  2. Speed. Pages per minute matters when many people share one machine or when you print long documents. A slow machine creates queues, and queues create complaints.
  3. Paper size and handling. Do you need A3? Do you use thick paper, envelopes or labels? Check how many trays the machine has and how much paper they hold, so staff are not refilling all day.
  4. Colour. Decide which departments truly need colour. Colour pages usually cost more than black-and-white ones, so some offices use one colour machine for the departments that need it and a black-and-white machine for everyone else.
  5. Scanning and document flow. Look at what happens to a scanned page: email, a shared folder, a document system? A machine that scans quickly and sends files where your team works saves more time than one that only copies fast.
  6. Security and control. For shared machines, look for PIN or card release for print jobs, user codes for tracking, and the ability to restrict who can use colour. These features protect confidential papers and help you see who prints what.
  7. Cost per page and consumables. Compare the whole running cost: toner, drums, service and spare parts, not just the machine price or monthly fee. Check whether the original toner is used and whether it is written in the contract.
  8. Space and layout. One large central machine is efficient but means a walk to the printer. Several smaller machines are convenient but can cost more to supply and maintain. Think about where people sit and how they move.

When a multifunction printer is usually the better fit

  • Your monthly volume is low to moderate
  • Several small teams need print, copy and scan in one place
  • Space is limited
  • Your team values simple operation and a lower starting cost
  • You want one machine per department or floor for convenience

When a copier-class machine is usually the better fit

  • Your volume is high, with large print and copy runs
  • You need speed, large paper capacity or finishing such as stapling and booklet making
  • Many people share one central machine
  • Document-heavy teams such as accounts, legal or administration use it all day
  • You want a machine built to run all day with fewer stops

Many offices end up with a mix: copier-class machines for busy shared areas and smaller multifunction printers for small teams or private offices.

Does renting change the decision?

Yes, because it lowers the risk of choosing wrong. When you buy, a machine that turns out too small or too large is yours to live with. With a rental, you can start with the machine that matches your current volume and review it after a few months, using real page counts.

Before signing, check the monthly page allowance, the price of extra pages, the toner type, service response time and what happens if you need to move to a larger or smaller machine.

Questions to ask any supplier before you decide

  • What monthly volume is this machine designed for, and how does it compare with mine?
  • What are the colour and black-and-white page prices?
  • Is the toner original from the manufacturer, and is that in the contract?
  • How fast does an engineer arrive, and what happens if the same fault keeps returning?
  • Can I move to a different machine if my needs change?
  • What security and tracking features are included?

A photocopier and a multifunction printer are not rivals so much as tools for different jobs. Map what each department does, check volume, speed, paper size, colour, scanning, security and running cost, and then pick the machine, or the mix of machines, that fits the work. The right choice is the one that keeps your office running smoothly without paying for capacity you never use.

Related Posts
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *

Get a free quote

Request A Quotation

We will soon contact you in touch